A newly released documentary delves into the life and contributions of Shambhu Nath De, Sipra Guha-Mukherjee and Obaid Siddiqi. We caught up with the director and producer to hear what went on behind the camera.
A discovery in Calcutta Medical College deemed worthy to win a Nobel Prize, test tubes at the University of Delhi that grew plants from just pollen in coconut water, the origins of two very powerful biological research institutions – these stories form the backbone of the documentary Written Out of History: Forgotten Indian Scientists, directed by Munmun Dhalaria, a National Geographic explorer and filmmaker, and produced by the Institute for Stem Cell Science and Regenerative Medicine (InSTEM) and the DBT/Wellcome Trust India Alliance.
The documentary film weaves a compelling narrative with the lives of three Indian scientists: Shambhu Nath De, former head of the bacteriology and pathology division of the Calcutta Medical College, Sipra Guha-Mukherjee, one of the founding faculty of the department of life sciences at Jawaharlal Nehru University in Delhi, and Obaid Siddiqi, founder of the TIFR-National Centre for Biological Sciences (TIFR-NCBS) in Bengaluru. The film highlights these scientists’ contributions to their disciplines, and the ways in which they changed the lives of those around them.
One narrative thread ties the three scientists together in the film: according to the filmmakers, their contributions have been virtually forgotten. Absent from public memory, the stories of these scientists, their work, their grit and gumption, survive in memories hidden in personal and institutional archives.
The film stands as both a celebratory and a cautionary tale for Indian science.
Telling stories of science – and making them exciting
According to Minhaj Sirajuddin, faculty at InSTEM and executive producer and scientific advisor of the film, the seeds of the documentary were first sown over a lunch conversation with his colleagues at the InSTEM campus in Bengaluru. The researchers were discussing which format could best be used to popularise the work of unsung scientists, and they concluded that a visual documentary-film format would be worth pursuing. “Science documentaries are popular on various platforms, but almost none of these are from India,” said Minhaj in an interview with TheLifeofScience.com. He roped in DBT/Wellcome Trust India Alliance and Munmun, and the idea started to become reality.
Munmun’s priority was to combine accurate science storytelling with touching aspects of the lives of these scientists, including their struggles. “I wanted to make science documentaries really exciting to watch,” said Munmun. Coupled with science animator Shraddha Nayak’s skills, the team effectively combined the life histories of each scientist with key highlights of their work that is conveyed through both scientifically viable and creative animation. The result is a fast-paced and gripping movie that can be watched either in three distinct parts, or as a whole.
Narrowing down the three scientists
Once the idea was set in motion, the next step was to select the scientists to be featured. The broad discipline was easier to narrow down: Minhaj’s biology background meant that he would be able to offer the most expertise in the domain of biology. This was complemented by Munmun’s background in documenting natural history. Moreover, according to Minhaj, “biology [as compared with physics and chemistry] has always been an underdog in the country”.
The tougher task was to narrow down the three biologists who they would feature. Shambhu Nath De’s (1915 – 1985) work stood out to them very clearly. “His was a fundamental discovery from a medical college in Kolkata that had a direct impact on public health. Yet, even microbiologists often do not know of his work,” Minhaj said. In fact, as the film itself shows, De’s grandson acknowledges not being aware of his grandfather’s seminal contribution to the eradication of cholera infections until he encountered “De’s Loop Method” – a method that De independently discovered to study cholera pathogenesis – in his medicine textbooks.
The team filming Shyamal De, son of Shambhu Nath De.
The film also highlights Sipra Guha-Mukherjee (1938 – 2007). Guha-Mukherjee had serendipitously discovered that it was possible to grow plants just from their anthers, i.e. the male reproductive organs. These organs contain pollen grains, which in turn contain a male gamete. The male gamete is haploid, meaning that it has only one set of chromosomes as compared with a diploid plant that has two sets. Being able to generate haploid plants meant that botanists could do sophisticated genetic experiments to bring together desirable characteristics (e.g. pest resistance and higher yield) and eliminate undesirable ones. “There was this serendipitous discovery made by a woman scientist in the 1960s. Women scientists have had a very hard time in the Indian science ecosystem, and most people in India are unaware of Sipra Guha-Mukherjee’s work,” Minhaj said.
The third pick was molecular geneticist and behavioural neurobiologist Obaid Siddiqi (1932 – 2013). Along with his student Veronica Rodrigues, Siddiqi used the fruit fly to study how smell and taste are sensed by the brain. He was not just a pathbreaking scientist, but also an institution-builder, having founded both the Molecular Biology unit at TIFR-Bombay, and the TIFR-NCBS in Bangalore. Material about Siddiqi would be convenient for the team to gather because a plethora of archival material about his life was available at NCBS Archives. Talking about the recent history of Indian science captured in the film Munmun said: “Towards the 1990s and the 2000s, things are looking up for Indian science. Indian science is getting funded. New institutions are being built. And, success stories are coming out. We wanted to end the documentary on this positive note.”
Lack of prior documentation
“There were no videos that I could refer back to, so as a visual communicator, things were rather difficult. But even for photos – including photos of them working in their labs – I had to rely on their family members.” – Munmun Dhalaria
Making the documentary was in no way an easy task. The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic corresponded closely to the time when the team began production. This significantly delayed their work, and extended the production process by over two years as compared with the initial plan for one year. But the pandemic was not the only troublemaker. Munmun was “shocked at how poorly the lives of the scientists of this country had been archived.” She was under the impression that since these were important people, their institutes or the government must have saved some of their work. However, the reality turned out to be very different: “There were no videos that I could refer back to, so as a visual communicator, things were rather difficult. But even for photos – including photos of them working in their labs – I had to rely on their family members.”
Pictures from the personal archives of Sipra Guha-Mukherjee
The lack of documentation meant that the project also became an archiving project in its own right. For example, Munmun mentions how the assistant director, Raj Shekhar, walked around the streets of Kolkata to find Shambhu Nath De’s house so that they could interview his son, Shyamal De. It is at his house that the team found original manuscripts on cholera that had not been given to any archive, but well-preserved by the De family: “Apart from the interview and spending hours there, we were also scanning materials to create archives in our own way”, said Munmun.
Similarly, in the case of Sipra Guha-Mukherjee, neither the Indian government, nor the Jawaharlal Nehru University – where she was one of the founding faculty of the school of life sciences – has any archive or museum. It is only when Guha-Mukherjee’s daughter, Barnali Mukherjee, took Munmun and team to her last residential house in Gurgaon that a new world of archival material unfolded in front of their eyes.
Munmun told TheLifeofScience.com that “[Barnali] had preserved everything in the house exactly the way her mother had left it. It was like walking into history. Her clothes, her books, her awards – all completely untouched. The fact that their children are keeping the memories of these scientists alive by building their own personal archives deeply touched me.”
Shambhu Nath De’s residence in Kolkata
Are the three scientists equally forgotten?
When it came to Obaid Siddiqi, the team had a different problem. Courtesy the NCBS Archives, there was a more-than-necessary amount of archival material available. Moreover, a lot had already been written and spoken about him, which meant that Munmun had to “hand pick a very few things that were useful to the kind of film we wanted to make,” she said.
So can the three scientists featured – Shambhu Nath De, Sipra Guha-Mukherjee and Obaid Siddiqi – be boxed under the same view of “forgotten”? While De and Guha-Mukherjee were relatively uncelebrated during their times, that wasn’t the case for Siddiqi. He received several awards from the Indian government and the science academies, including the Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar Prize in 1976. There are entire galleries dedicated to him in the NCBS Archives. How did, then, Siddiqi find a space in a documentary featuring “forgotten” Indian scientists?
Minhaj agrees that at least in the context of the Indian science ecosystem, Siddiqi’s memory is still alive. However, Munmun pointed out that “as a regular citizen of this country – who is not a scientist – I had no idea who Obaid Siddiqi was. Therefore, choosing to feature Obaid was a perspective of somebody from the outside looking in.” Munmun also reminded us that the film’s target audience is not restricted to people in the Indian science ecosystem; rather, the film hopes to reach more people outside this ecosystem.
With the documentary having been watched ~6000 times on YouTube, does this mean that the Indian science ecosystem is warming up to more science documentaries? Minhaj sees a “tremendous future” for this format in India. “That is because we have so many stories,” he said.
Note: All pictures used in the post have been provided by Munmun Dhalaria. The featured image forthis post was created by the author using some of the pictures provided.
Watch the movie at the link below:
3. Visvesvaraya. Born on 15 September 1860, Sir Mokshagundam Visvesvaraya was a notable Indian engineer, scholar, statesman and the Diwan of Mysore during 1912 to 1918.Who is the No 1 scientist in India? ›
C.V. Raman. Dr. C.V. Raman (Chandrasekhara Venkata Raman) was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1930 for his revolutionary work on light scattering. Born in Tiruchirapalli on November 7, 1888, he was the first Asian and non-White beneficiary of the Nobel Prize in the Science field.Who is famous Indian scientist? ›
|Name||Field||Most noted award/fellowship|
|Chandrasekhara Venkata Raman (C.V Raman)||Physics||Nobel Prize in Physics|
|Srinivasa Ramanujan||Mathematics||Fellow of the Royal Society|
|Satyendra Nath Bose||Mathematics, physics|
|M. S. Swaminathan||Genetics|
Asima Chatterjee was the first lady scientist elected as the general president of the Indian Science Congress in 1975.Who is the Queen of scientist? ›
Carl Friedrich Gauss, the famous mathematician after which one of the prizes is named, is said to have stated that mathematics is 'the queen of sciences'.Who is called Mother of India? ›
|Sarojini Naidu (Nightingale of India)||India||Mother of the Nation|
|Dame Whina Cooper||New Zealand||Mother of the Nation|
|Miss. Fatima Jinnah||Pakistan||Mother of the Nation/Leader of Pakistani Women Rights|
|Winnie Madikizela-Mandela||South Africa||Mother of the Nation|
Asima Chatterjee was the first woman to be awarded a Doctor of Science by an Indian University - in 1944, by the University of Calcutta.Who is India's youngest scientist? ›
Gopal Jee, Youngest Scientist of India, was there at Kerala Samajam Model School on 25th August, 2022 for a session with students of Std. XI and XII.Who is No 1 scientist ever? ›
Albert Einstein is one of the most famous scientists in the world. He used to be an eccentric person who was perhaps the only scientist in the world who has become such a household name. His theories of relativity, gravitation and his understanding of molecules have defined new approaches in science.Who is the scientist of India 2022? ›
National Science Day 2022: Celebrating Indian Science Wizards—Raman, Bose, Saha, Chandrasekhar, and Bhabha.
The first known woman to earn a university chair in a scientific field of studies was eighteenth-century Italian scientist Laura Bassi. Gender roles were largely deterministic in the eighteenth century and women made substantial advances in science.Who is the famous lady scientist? ›
The Polish scientist studied at the Sorbonne, where she became the head of the physics lab there in the early 1900s — when women really did not teach science at European universities — and pioneered research in radioactivity. She and her husband jointly won the Nobel Prize in 1903.
Peter Reich, director of the Institute for Global Change Biology at the U-M School for Environment and Sustainability, has been ranked the No. 1 ecology and evolution scientist in the world and in the United States by Research.com, a prominent academic platform for scientists.Who is the best scientist in 2022? ›
The highest cited scientist is Joel Nathan Butler from Fermilab with 413,256 citations. The average H-index for the top 1% of scientists is 230 against an average of 131 for the top 1000 scientists included in the ranking.Who is the best scientist in India 2022? ›
J.B. Singh, a Panjab University professor, who works in the field of high energy particle physics, tops the list of scientists from India. He ranks at number 124 in the world. Singh was part of the international team of scientists in 1995 which discovered the top quark — a subatomic particle in 1995.Who is the king of math? ›
Srinivasa Ramanujan is known as the king of maths in India due to his contribution by working on the Analytical Theory of Numbers, Elliptical Function, and Infinite Series.Who is the father of maths? ›
The Father of Math is the great Greek mathematician and philosopher Archimedes.Who is father of science? ›
Albert Einstein called Galileo the “father of modern science.” Galileo Galilei was born on February 15, 1564, in Pisa, Italy but lived in Florence, Italy for most of his childhood.Who married his own mother in India? ›
|Hamida Banu Begum|
|Died||29 August 1604 (aged 76–77) Agra, Mughal Empire (present-day India)|
|Burial||30 August 1604 Humayun's Tomb, Delhi|
|Spouse||Humayun ( m. 1540; d. 1556)|
You would be surprised to know that the Indian subcontinent has been flourishing for around 5,000-6,000 years and its peoples joined together to form a civilization in roughly 1500 BCE when they created the Vedic Civilization, which laid out the foundations of Hinduism.Who designed Indian flag first? ›
Who designed the flag of India? The design of the flag of India that was first presented in 1921 to Mahatma Gandhi, leader of the All-India Congress, was created by Pingali (or Pinglay) Venkayya.Who is the youngest female scientist? ›
Gitanjali Rao (born November 19, 2005) is an American inventor, author, scientist and engineer, and science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) promoter and social activist.Who was the first male scientist in India? ›
|Sir Chandrasekhara Venkata Raman FNA, FASc, FIAS, FASB, FRS|
|Institutions||Indian Finance Department Rajabazar Science College (University of Calcutta) Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science Indian Institute of Science Raman Research Institute|
Anandibai Joshi (1865-1887)
Medicine (1885, Philadelphia), Anandibai Joshi, the first Hindu woman to obtain a medical degree in the Western hemisphere, was born Yamuna Joshi on March 31, 1865 in Poona, India.
|Srinivasa Ramanujan FRS|
|Born||22 December 1887 Erode, Mysore State, British Indian Empire|
|Died||26 April 1920 (aged 32) Kumbakonam, Madras, British India|
|Other names||Srinivasa Ramanujan Aiyangar|
|Known for||Highest Vertified IQ of 225 Youngest CCNA certificate holder|
An innovative approach to problem-solving means Kevin Kittle has developed truly pioneering solutions when it comes to the world of powder coatings. It's fair to say Kevin Kittle, our 2022 Scientist of the Year, has a proud history with AkzoNobel.Who is a famous scientist today? ›
|Name||Field of Influence|
|1. Alain Aspect||Quantum Theory|
|2. David Baltimore||Virology—HIV & Cancer|
|3. Allen Bard||Electrochemistry|
|4. Timothy Berners- Lee||Computer Science (WWW)|
|Niels Bohr||Bohr Theory of the Atom|
|Wilhelm Conrad Rontgen||X-rays|
Tamil Nadu is home to at least 100 of the top 2% scientists in the world, according to a database developed by Stanford University .Which country has most scientists? ›
|Rank||Country||Scientific publications per capita (in ppm)|
Aristotle is considered by many to be the first scientist, although the term postdates him by more than two millennia. In Greece in the fourth century BC, he pioneered the techniques of logic, observation, inquiry and demonstration.Who was smarter Einstein or Newton? ›
Both agreed Newton did more for science and humanity. 86.2 per cent of scientists preferred Newton's science and 60.9 per cent of them acknowledged his greater benefits to mankind. Einstein had to stand on Newton's shoulders to reach for his own scientific ideas. Take your pick.Who is the king of science in India? ›
Anurag - New Delhi,Delhi : Physics is the King of Science ..What is scientist III? ›
Scientist III - Biotech develop and conduct basic and applied research projects. Utilize advanced technologies to study biological, molecular and chemical processes. Being a Scientist III - Biotech synthesize and analyze DNA, proteins and other molecules to develop new drugs, medical protocols, and products.Who is the third scientist in the world? ›
#3 Marie Curie (1867-1964)
Her research also led to the discovery of a new radioactive element, which she named polonium. Moreover, she discovered another element called radium, which helped take the study of radioactive elements forward.
|Satyendra Nath Bose FRS, MP, PV|
|Bose in 1925|
|Born||1 January 1894 Calcutta, Bengal Presidency, British Raj|
|Died||4 February 1974 (aged 80) Calcutta, West Bengal, India|
|Alma mater||University of Calcutta|
Common types of scientist
An agronomist specializes in soil and crops. An astronomer studies outer space, stars, planets and galaxies. A botanist specializes in botany, the study plants. A chemist specializes in chemistry.
Science is a broad career field with many specialties and areas of study. The three main branches of science are physical science, earth science and life science, and they each have different career applications.
Some of them are rightfully well-known, like Marie Curie, Ada Lovelace and Rosalind Franklin. But others, like fossil hunter Mary Anning and NASA pioneer Katherine Johnson, aren't such household names. So, we've put together this list of 22 women in science history who deserve to be remembered for their work.Who is World 1st scientist? ›
Aristotle is considered by many to be the first scientist, although the term postdates him by more than two millennia. In Greece in the fourth century BC, he pioneered the techniques of logic, observation, inquiry and demonstration.Who is the greatest scientist in the world 2022? ›
The highest cited scientist is Joel Nathan Butler from Fermilab with 413,256 citations. The average H-index for the top 1% of scientists is 230 against an average of 131 for the top 1000 scientists included in the ranking.Who is Indian youngest scientist? ›
Jamshedpur, Aug 24: Kerala Public School, Kadma organized session with India's youngest scientist Gopal Jee on Wednesday. Gopal Jee by the age of 17, had done 11 inventions. Some of his inventions such as the Banana bio cell, has been published around the world.Who is the first youngest scientist in India? ›
About Gopal Jee:
He currently served as a researcher and research director of Navneet Industries. By the age of 17, He had done 10 inventions, 2 of which are provisional patents. Some of his inventions, such as the Banana bio cell, have been published around the world.
J.B. Singh, a Panjab University professor, who works in the field of high energy particle physics, tops the list of scientists from India. He ranks at number 124 in the world. Singh was part of the international team of scientists in 1995 which discovered the top quark — a subatomic particle in 1995.Who is the present best scientist? ›
|Name||1. Alain Aspect|
|Field of Influence||Quantum Theory|
|Name||26. Martin Karplus|
|Field of Influence||Quantum Chemistry|